Recalling 1968 Victoria Carnarvon All Stars, PONY League WS

3B Bill Paul tags out Maui player, Anthony Takitani, at the 1968 Pony League World Series. Fifty years later, the memories still matter.

1968 Carnarvon All Stars

The Summer of ‘68: A Victoria Baseball Memoir

The world was changing, but for a Victoria 14-year-old, the game stayed the same.

By Bill Paul

Fifty years later, the memories still matter.

A large crowd is watching a ball game on a warm Sunday afternoon at Sunbury Park in Delta. It’s Aug. 11, 1968. I’m 14 years-old and play third base on a Pony League team called Victoria Carnarvon. I wear a white jersey with red lettering across the front. My face is brown from too much sun and I wear my socks pulled up high. We’re playing the Prince Albert Cubs from Saskatchewan. This is an important game. The winner will represent Canada at the Pony League World Series in Washington, Pa. I’m feeling a little nervous.

It’s the final inning and we’re ahead by one run. Two men are out and it’s the last at bats for Prince Albert. Daryl Kubicek, all hustle and grit, has just made a game-saving throw for us from deep in the outfield. Prince Albert has the tying run on third base. The game’s on the line. Bob Burrows, our manager, brings Tom Craig in to pitch. We’re in a bit of a jam and Craig has a knack for getting hitters out late in the game. Craig is known for his modesty and has asked his parents not to come to the game. They come anyway and watch the game on pins and needles. I glance over at Craig. Strands of his hair are covered in sweat. His face is red. “We need just one more out,” I think to myself.

At bat for Prince Albert is Davey-Joe Prytula. Craig pauses and then throws a pitch on the inside of the plate. Prytula swings and hits a slow rolling ball down the third base line. I run in, field the ball and make a high throw to first base. No matter. Darryl Goddard is lean and lanky like his dad. Goddard plants his right foot on first base and stretches out his glove. My throw beats the runner. The game is over. Whoops of joy. We throw our baseball gloves in the air and rush to mob Tom Craig. Holy cow. We’re going to Pennsylvania.

I think we had to pinch ourselves. The boys from Prince Albert didn’t give up. They were a tight-knit group. Nine players on their team played hockey together in the winter back home. We had a bit of luck, and good pitching. Glen Wallace is our ace. He is six-foot-three, (tall even for pony league) with wide shoulders and sandy brown hair. He pitches with authority and can hit the ball a mile. He makes everyone on the team a better player.

Then there’s Ray Andre. He’s a fierce competitor who wears his ball hat down low and throws part sidearm. His best pitch is a lively fastball that darts and swerves as it crosses the plate. There are others. Derrick Fuller is a hard out, a dangerous hitter. Martin Winstanley is a solid, all-around ball player. When both players were younger they thrived playing under Bob Burrows at Fireman”s Park.

Fireman’s Park was where it all started. The Little League park was tucked away among the quiet, leafy streets of Oak Bay. I remember eating pixie sticks in the dugout with my teammates. I remember the sweet follow-through swing of Donnie Miles and the great pitching rivalry between Albert Wells and Walt Burrows. And I remember Doug Hudlin (who later became a member of the Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame) umpiring on Sunday afternoons. He had a friendly, baritone voice. It was all part of the simple pleasures of playing minor league baseball in Victoria. All ancient history now.

On Monday, a headline in the sports section of the Victoria Daily Times read “Carnarvons Head for World Series.” A couple of our players were interviewed by Ida Clarkson, a local legend on CHEK-TV. Community organizations helped raise funds, and five days later on a Friday morning we met at Carnarvon Park. Dressed in our Sunday best, we drove to the airport and got on a plane to the United States.

My mom, Jean, (some of her friends call her Gina), hemmed my pair of dress pants for the trip. For years she came to my ball games and sat in the bleachers with other parents. She was petite and outgoing and dressed in a cardigan. There was usually a pack of Du Maurier cigarettes in her purse. My dad, Alex, preferred to sit in the grass along the right field line. He was a longshoreman and a long-time New York Yankees fan. During a game at Layritz Park, the story goes, he threatened to bop someone in the nose if they didn’t stop bad-mouthing our team.

At the park on that Friday morning, as we gather to start the trip, I notice that our coach Bud Brice, is not there. Are Mr. Holmes and Mr. Mullins coming instead? Standing on the grass, dressed in a sports jacket and tie, is Bob Burrows. Burrows has four sons of his own who play sports, primarily baseball and basketball. He has a rumpled air about him. He’s in his mid-40s and wears a fedora tilted back on his head. His voice is gentle but firm and he always has an encouraging word to put you at ease. “You can do it buddy,” he might say, clapping his hands together.

My teammates and I wear ties and black nylon jackets with “Canada” crests sewn on by Ray Andre’s mom, Elka. We mill around and my mom takes a team picture with her Kodak Instamatic. Billy Crawford is smiling, beaming really. Russ Walker, who is full of spunk, has his eyes closed. Wayne Simpson (nicknamed Wiener) has a stocky build and red freckles. Terry Watchman wears green jeans and brown strapped sandals. Kip Jones sports skinny sideburns. It is after all 1968. We look hopeful. Tentative.

The trip east is inauspicious. We board a Viscount airplane at the small Victoria airport and it blows three tires when it lands in Calgary. Then on to Cleveland, where we are told our luggage is lost. The airport in Cleveland smells of stale air conditioning and cigarette smoke. Some of us play cards. Others buy hamburgers for 15 cents at McDonald’s. I recall watching people as they moved about the airport. It’s the first time in my life that I’ve seen people from so many different walks of life. There are black Americans and groups of businessmen wearing suits and ties. What I know about the United States is what I have learned from reading the headlines in the newspaper or from watching the CBS Evening News on television. There’s a war on and a presidential election is being held in November. America feels different. It has a history that I know nothing about.

Eventually we arrive in Washington, a town 45 kilometres south of Pittsburgh. Located in a county known for producing coal, Washington is often described as an educated, blue-collar town. We stay in a red brick dormitory at the Washington Jefferson College (founded in 1781). In the school cafeteria at lunch time there’s corn-on-the-cob and iced tea. Many of the buildings in town are made out of brick or stone. Near the top of the hill on Main Street is the George Washington Hotel, built in 1922.

A faint, sweet scent hangs in the air. Washington reminds me of small-town life described in a short story I read once in the eighth grade.

Further down the street is a movie theatre and a five-and-dime store. The maple or elm trees and hills that dot the neighbourhood are a rich, dark green colour. The weather is muggy. A faint, sweet scent hangs in the air. Washington reminds me of small-town life described in a short story I read once in the eighth grade.

It’s unfamiliar and not like Victoria. Victoria was idyllic and, for the most part, middle class. Washington seemed older. It had more history. It was a small town and the mood was different. I knew nothing about what people did for a living there or what people thought about their country. I don’t know what to expect in the tournament. In other words, I think we may be the underdogs. Both the North Carolina and California teams have big, strong players.

Most American kids have been practicing and playing ball for years. Baseball’s their national pastime. On our third day in Washington, our team travels to Pittsburgh to watch a Pirates’ game at Forbes Field (the great Roberto Clemente is playing right field for the Pirates). Between innings I take a stroll, survey the faces in the crowd and take in the ambience. Later in my room I write a post card to my parents. I say: “We went to the ball game. The Pirates won. All the teams are here now. Having a nice time. Bill.” I don’t tell them the tap water tastes funny. My roommates Tom Craig, Kip Jones and I sleep on bunk beds. The humidity makes it hard to sleep at night.

In our first game at Pony League Field on Aug. 19 we play a team from Maui. The park is spacious and ringed with grandstands. The outfield grass is freshly mowed. The Trinettes, a high-school, female drill team carrying hoop batons, will perform between baseball games. There’s a threat of a thunderstorm. Around 4,000 people, dressed in short sleeves, cut-offs and slacks watch the game. Some men wear straw hats.

By the sixth inning, Maui is ahead 1-0. Pitching for them is a smooth throwing left-hander, Terrance Takahashi. We need base runners. Up at bat for us is Kip Jones who lines a pitch off the left field fence for a double. Russ Walker, the faster player on our team, is sent out to run for Jones. He scores when Martin Winstanley, our shortstop, strokes a single. After Winstanley steals second base, Glen Wallace drives him in with a base hit. Loud cheers from our dugout as Winstanley slides home safely, We’re up by a run. Maui gets one last chance. I trot out to third base.

Glen Wallace starts the seventh inning by walking Anthony Takitani. After a passed ball, Takitani charges into second base. His aggressive base-running style has caught me off guard. Ashley Douglass, our second baseman, senses something is up. He moves closer to the bag at second and rubs the bill of his cap. The pick-off play is on. As Wallace turns to throw to Douglass, Takitani sprints towards third base.

I immediately turn and face Douglass and I make sure my feet are even with the third base bag. Douglass’s throw is perfect. Takitani slides head first stretching out his right hand towards the base. I sweep my glove up and tag him on the shoulder. My body is taut. The crowd stands up. What’s the call? The umpire, crouching near third base, raises his right arm and yells “out!” I feel my adrenaline subside and then relief. The last two Maui hitters ground out. It’s a storybook ending.

Sometimes in between games we are left to our own devices. One day I walk four blocks to Main Street and buy the new Doors album, Waiting for the Sun. It has a fold-out cover that pleases me to no end. Later in mid-week a few teenage girls we befriended after the Maui game invite Ashley Douglass, Derrick Fuller and I to a matinee starring Sidney Poitier. There is an openness about the girls that is engaging. A couple of them talk with a slight twang in their voices. We meet them in front of the Penn Theater on Main Street. Fuller has dark wavy hair and a carefree attitude. He and his date are smitten with one another. After the movie Douglass gets a ride from someone’s older brother. Douglass sits in the front seat. Some soul music is playing on the radio. But the older brother wants to change the station. He doesn’t like black music. In an e-mail to me earlier this year, Douglass recalled the incident: “I heard racism for the first time”, he said. “It blew me away. I was so naive at that time.”

Victoria Carnarvon at the Pony League World Series in Washington, Penn. “All part of the simple pleasures of playing minor ball in Victoria ..

Our next game is against Caracas, Venezuela. Caracas won the Latin American title by beating teams from Cuba, Mexico and Puerto Rico. Some of the players on the Caracas team look like they stepped out of a young men’s fashion magazine. They’re a good hitting team and they play the game with a certain flair. In the second inning they score four runs on six hits off Ray Andre. Peter Michielin, a bright 13-year-old with a mop of hair, relieves Andre. Michielin is a finesse pitcher and he pitches well, but we lose 7-2. Maybe our luck is running out.

Two night later under the lights we play Covina, California. The Covina players wear old-fashioned cloth uniforms with black lettering. On the bus on the way to the game I overhear two Covina players talking to each other. Their voices are flat. One player asks the other: “How much do you think we’ll beat these guys by?”

Before the first inning is over we misplay routine ground balls, commit seven errors and gradually lose our poise. I recall leaping for a ball that’s hit just over the reach of my glove. Pangs of frustration follow. A sinking feeling comes over me. The runs pile up on the score board and the game goes sideways. After five innings the game is stopped due to the score (it’s called the mercy rule). Final tally is 26-3 for Covina.

Al Kubicek, Daryl’s father, is at the game and is quoted in The Daily Colonist. “They couldn’t pick up the ball. They couldn’t throw it straight when they did get it under control. It was their worst game of the season.”

There’s nowhere to hide after a loss like that. It’s a humbling experience. We’re tired, disappointed and a bit rattled. Still in our uniforms we walk in groups of two and three carrying our equipment to the chartered city bus parked just past the first base dugout and bleachers. The crowd has thinned out and it feels less muggy. I notice a few of the girls that we befriended are crying. No time for ceremony or farewell hugs. On the bus some of us wave goodbye to them through the rear window.

I write this 50 years later sitting at a desk in my basement, I replay that game sometimes. How did we lose by such a lopsided score? Was our team in disarray and ill-prepared? Were we intimidated by the size and the confidence of the Covina players? Was it a combination of the sticky August heat and physical fatigue that did us in?

I know Covina was the better team. I do have a theory though. Sometimes during any given ball game, a team ends up making a few mistakes in an inning, cannot recover and then the game takes on a momentum all its own. Maybe that’s what happened to us or maybe we were just plain lousy that night. Hard to know.

Losing to Covina knocks us out of the tournament. The next morning in the dorm we stuff our belongings and souvenirs, including miniature wooden baseball bats and Hawaiian hats made from palm leaves, into our travelling bags and climb onto another rented bus to start the trip home.

We fly from Pittsburgh to O’Hare Airport in Chicago for a connecting flight to Canada. It’s Saturday, Aug. 24. Young volunteers in the main terminal are handing out Eugene McCarthy for President campaign buttons. In two days the Democratic National Convention is scheduled to start in Chicago. Robert Kennedy’s bid for the nomination had ended in early June when he was assassinated in a Los Angeles hotel.

The convention was a choice between McCarthy, who promised to get the U.S. out of Vietnam, and Hubert Humphrey, the vice-president. Humphrey won. In the streets near the convention centre anti-war protestors — some of whom were probably volunteers for McCarthy — would battle with the National Guard. Many protesters would be injured.

But we are insulated from the larger world. We are innocents abroad: a group of boys fumbling through adolescence.On the plane we talk among ourselves. High school will start in one week. I think Bob Burrows, his fedora pushed back on his head, felt it was an honour for a group of 13-14-year-old boys from Victoria to play in the Pony League World Series. I can’t argue. I think for all of us it was an adventure.

Playing baseball was fun. Special. I felt like I was on top of the world playing a game where anything could happen. There was camaraderie and rivalry. At times it could be intense. Baseball is a game of details. Sometimes good things happen. All of that may sound corny. The thing is, I have a fondness for those days.

A Victoria Baseball Family: Bob Burrows and three of his four sons. From left to right: Bob Burrows Jr., skipper Bob Burrows, Don Burrows and Walt Burrows, currentlly a scout with the Minnesota Twins.

Postscript – 1968 Carnarvon All Stars Manager Bob Burrows

The manager of the 1968 Victoria Carnarvons, Bob Burrows, had four sons: Bob Jr., Don, Walt, and John. All four were excellent athletes and high profile players in the Victoria baseball, fastpitch, and basketball communities.

Bob Jr. was Victoria’s top all round athlete during the 60’s and 70’s and after playing basketball for Canada at the 1967 Pan Am games he turned down a a Seattle Supersonics draft in and signed a pro baseball contract with Kansas City. After an injury ended Bob Jr.‘s pro career, he played with Don and Walt on Victoria fastpitch teams that won multiple Canadian Championships.

In 2011, Don Burrows was inducted to the Oak Bay High School sports hall of fame.

Walt Burrows was the Canadian Supervisor for the MLB Scouting Bureau for many years and is now the Minnesota Twins Area Scout in Canada.

John Burrows played on the Victoria Carnarvon team that represented Canada at the 1969 Pony League World Series. Bob Burrows great grandson, Josh Burrows, is a member of the 2019 Victoria Eagles Bantam Premier team, so the Burrows legacy continues.

Bill Paul lives in Vancouver. He loves listening to baseball games on the radio. (A shorter version of this story first appeared in The Tyee.ca)